
Brown troutBrown, rainbow and brook troutFish on your own. Guide prices are optional; check licence, permit and access requirements before going.
- Guide, per angler
- $225–263
- Public access
- Good
- Crowding
- Medium

Big Indian to Phoenicia and Mount Tremper, New York · USA
Forecast data loads here when available. Official weather source ↗
Day ratings weigh rain first (it raises and colors the river), then wind.
Flow: USGS Esopus Creek at Coldbrook, USGS Esopus Creek at Allaben. Recent readings are provisional. Normal range: the middle half of past flows for these dates. Forecast: National Weather Service.
Apr–Jun and Sep–Nov; trophy rainbows early spring and late fall Wrong?
Wild rainbows dominate the creek around Phoenicia, and cold water from the Shandaken Portal (Schoharie Reservoir) shapes flow and temperature from Allaben down to the Ashokan Reservoir. Portal releases and heavy rain can leave it high and muddy for days.
You came from a self-guided day-trip search. The calculator starts with one fishing day and no guide. Licence, permit, travel and any other costs still apply.
Thin local coverage: April and November left out, and June, September and October have only two flies each. NYSDEC names Isonychia, BWO, sulphur and late stoneflies as the main hatches but gives no months.
From local shops and guides: catskillflies.com · riverreporter.com · dec.ny.gov. Ask the nearest shop what's working this week.
From perfectflystore.com. Guides usually supply rods and flies on a guided day; ask when you book.
These are the businesses this page's prices and fly lists come from. A listing isn't an endorsement, and nobody pays to be here.
Fly into SWF Newburgh, then 1 hr. About 61 miles (98 km) by road.
Open in Google Maps · Directions from SWF
Driving from Albany about 1 hr 30 min, New York City about 2 hr 40 min, Scranton about 2 hr 50 min, Hartford about 3 hr.
Rates, seasons and access change. Tell us what's wrong and, if you can, where you saw it.

Brown troutBrown, rainbow and brook troutFish on your own. Guide prices are optional; check licence, permit and access requirements before going.

Rainbow troutStocked rainbows, browns and brook trout; some wild brook and brown troutFish on your own. Guide prices are optional; check licence, permit and access requirements before going.

Brown troutWild brown trout, rainbows, brook troutFish on your own. Guide prices are optional; check licence, permit and access requirements before going.